Fragments of a Fragile Order: Phasing Out Free Speech
From late-night TV to federal deployments, we unpack the converging forces eroding American democracy and the urgent role of resistance.
In this episode of the Art of Citizenry Podcast, host Manpreet Kaur Kalra and producer Aly Honoré take a step back from the headlines to explore what they reveal about the state of American democracy, culture, and free speech.
From the suspension of Jimmy Kimmel Live and mass doxing campaigns reminiscent of McCarthyism, to the militarization of cities and the campaign to “Free Ben & Jerry’s,” these stories are more than isolated flashpoints. Together, they paint a troubling picture of democratic fragility and the creeping rise of authoritarianism.
Join us as we unpack the escalating threats to free speech—from censorship and defamation lawsuits to corporate pressure and racialized violence. We connect the dots between media, governance, and power, revealing how dissent is being stifled and narratives tightly controlled—and why independent voices and collective resistance matter now more than ever.
“When that space for scrutiny is narrowed, whether through censorship, intimidation, or the co-opting of media outlets, the public’s access to truth is replaced with narratives carefully engineered to reinforce the power of an authoritarian regime.”
— Manpreet Kaur Kalra, Art of Citizenry
Reversing the judgment in Vasquez Perdomo v. Noem from two lower courts that barred immigration agents from stopping individuals without reasonable suspicion, the Court’s ruling allows for agents to rely on racial identifiers such as:
⏰ Timestamps:
00:55 Trump’s $15 Billion Defamation Lawsuit Against The New York Times
03:52 Disney-Owned ABC Pulls Jimmy Kimmel! Live!
10:25 Jerry Greenfield Leaves Ben & Jerry’s
15:49 The Erasure of Racial Violence in the Wake of Charlie Kirk
18:50 Deployment of Federal Forces for “Crime Control”
21:34 How We Fight Back
What emerges is an ecosystem of control: voices silenced through lawsuits, narratives erased through selective coverage, and public space militarized to cement that erasure. Together, they show a contracting democracy.
📺 Support Public & Independent Media
As corporate giants tighten their grip on news and entertainment, independent institutions need us more than ever. Support independent journalism (like this show), support PBS and your local public radio station, check out films and journalism through your local public library, and subscribe to nonprofit or local outlets. Every dollar, stream, and library card helps sustain accessible, community-driven media outside corporate control.
“When that space for scrutiny is narrowed, whether through censorship, intimidation, or the co-opting of media outlets, the public’s access to truth is replaced with narratives carefully engineered to reinforce the power of an authoritarian regime.”
— Manpreet Kaur Kalra
Resources, Citations & References
The Washington Post Fired Me — But My Voice Will Not Be Silenced by Karen Attiah
Why Washington Post Fired Me — the official termination letter by Karen Attiah
Legal experts say pulling Jimmy Kimmel from air may amount to illegal ‘jawboning’ - NPR
A Man Was Lynched Yesterday - NAACP Post on Instagram
Ben & Jerry’s co-founder Jerry Greenfield resigns over dispute with owner Unilever - NPR
Support the Podcast
Art of Citizenry is 100% listener-supported. Every contribution helps us continue producing research-intensive episodes and paying our small but mighty team. If this episode resonates with you, consider supporting our work:
✍🏽 Upgrade your account to paid on Substack!
💸 Make a one-time contribution here: visit.artofcitizenry.com/paypal
💌 Become a monthly contributor via Patreon: patreon.com/manpreetkalra
⭐️ Subscribe now to Art of Citizenry wherever you listen to podcasts and leave a 5 star review.
I want to hear your reflections — share your thoughts in the comments section. If you found this newsletter insightful, please like and share it forward! Thanks for reading.